Definitions and practical tools
Editorial practical tool
The additionality test
An editorial worksheet drawing on the book's guardrails and catalytic vehicle questions.
- Last reviewed
- Related chapter
- Philanthropy as Amplifier
These are editorial tools prepared for this library, not institutional standards. Use them as questions for discussion and professional advice.
Before committing to a catalytic position, write one-paragraph answers to each of these. If any answer is weak, the position is probably not additional.
- Name the capital that you expect to follow yours. Be specific: which institutions, roughly how much.
- For each, state what it would have done without your commitment. Would it have entered later? On different terms? Not at all? What is the evidence for that answer, beyond the manager's assertion?
- If the honest answer to question 2 is "roughly the same thing, a little later," stop. Your capital would be a subsidy, not a catalyst.
- State the smallest commitment that would still change the answer to question 2. That is your proportionate size.
- State what will cause your layer to step down, recycle, or exit once the following capital is established. If nothing will, the layer is permanent, and permanent concessional capital is a subsidy by another name.
Sources
Educational material, not investment, legal or tax advice. Reported figures and review dates reflect the cited sources and editorial review; they are not live data.
