Definitions and practical tools
Editorial practical tool
Reading an impact or mobilisation claim
An editorial worksheet drawing on the book's guardrails and catalytic vehicle questions.
- Last reviewed
- Related chapter
- Philanthropy as Amplifier
These are editorial tools prepared for this library, not institutional standards. Use them as questions for discussion and professional advice.
When a report says "X million mobilised" or "Y people reached," apply these questions before quoting the figure.
- Who reported it? The organisation that took the catalytic position, or an independent party?
- What is the denominator? Committed, deployed, or something else?
- What is the counterfactual? Does the report say what would have happened without the intervention, and how that was estimated?
- Is this an output (loans made, people enrolled) or an outcome (incomes raised, health improved)? Reports often present the first as if it were the second.
- Is this a target, a projection, or a result? Look for the reporting period.
- If several investors funded the same thing, has each claimed the whole result? (MacArthur's attribution problem.)
- Does the organisation acknowledge any of the above limits? Those that do (MedAccess, MacArthur, IDH in this library) are generally more reliable than those that do not.
Sources
Educational material, not investment, legal or tax advice. Reported figures and review dates reflect the cited sources and editorial review; they are not live data.
