Failures and lessons
Delay and design limitation (fund continues; the manager has published its own lessons)
IDH Farmfit Fund: a catalytic rule that became the bottleneck
Delay and design limitation (fund continues; the manager has published its own lessons). What was attempted, what happened, what is documented and what can be learned.
- Last reviewed
- Related chapter
- Chapter Five, step 4 (build the stack) and step 6 (milestones and release conditions); the humility guardrail
- Sectors
- Food, agriculture
- Geography
- Asia, Africa, Latin America
- Vehicles
- Blended finance fund
What was attempted
The IDH Farmfit Fund (case 5) was designed with a rule that looks like good catalytic discipline: every Farmfit investment had to bring a commercial co-investor with it, deal by deal. The rule was intended to guarantee additionality and to ensure that every concessional euro mobilised a commercial one.
What happened
Six years in, the fund had deployed a little over half its EUR 100 million. IDH's own January 2026 reflection names the co-investment requirement as a cause: aligning a commercial co-investor in a high-risk sector was slow, and smaller or more complex deals were delayed or did not proceed. The fund's technical assistance was also found to be oriented toward impact measurement and post-investment support rather than the investment readiness that would have made deals easier to close. IDH now recommends portfolio-level mobilisation targets rather than deal-level requirements.
What is documented and what is not
Documented: the deployment figure, the mobilisation figure, IDH's five design dilemmas, and its recommended changes. Not extracted by the library: the findings of the Dutch Government's independent mid-term review, which should be read in full before any judgement about the fund's overall performance.
Why this is in the failures section
Not because the fund failed. Because the mechanism that was meant to make it catalytic slowed it down, and the manager has been unusually candid about why. The book's Chapter Five, step 6 says catalytic capital should be staged, conditional, and adaptive. The Farmfit rule was conditional but not adaptive: it did not relax as the fund learned which deals could carry a co-investor and which could not.
Lesson for catalytic philanthropy
Write the additionality test at the level where it can be met. A requirement that every single transaction prove its own mobilisation will stop the transactions that most need catalytic capital, because those are the ones commercial investors are slowest to join. Portfolio-level targets, with reporting that shows which deals carried co-investors and which did not, preserve the discipline without the bottleneck.
Sources
Educational material, not investment, legal or tax advice. Reported figures and review dates reflect the cited sources and editorial review; they are not live data.
